
It’s VC Groundhog Day. A pile of founders are raising this quarter or next, and I feel like I’m having the same conversation each day.
A brilliant founder walks me through the deck. The factory they need to build, the engineers they need to hire, the regulatory timeline, the demo that’s finally ready to become productized. Every detail is correct, every detail has been polished for weeks.
Founders have been handed a mountain of storytelling advice, and nearly all of it covers two plots:
Who they are and how they got here.
The problem and how they’ll solve it.
But every raise carries a third story, and it’s the one the person across the table is reading. Where is this company on its own arc? It’s the question I’ve asked every founder this quarter, and I’m starting to sound like a broken record.
“We just beat every competitor on a technical benchmark,” is how the founder tells it. What I hear is: the science works, and now we find out if it’s a business.
The founder is describing a situation. I’m watching a shape.
Nobody explained that difference better than Kurt Vonnegut, who argued that every story has a shape, and there are far fewer shapes than there are stories. He used to prove it with a stick of chalk1.
He’d draw a line up the side of the board for good fortune and bad, and a line along the bottom for beginning to end. Then he’d plot Cinderella.

She starts near the bottom, cleaning the floor. The fairy godmother lifts her one gift at a time: the dress, the slippers, the carriage, the ball. At midnight she drops back down. Then the prince becomes a little too obsessed with feet, the slipper fits, and Vonnegut would draw her shooting off the top of the board.2
Now draw the same chart for a company. Time runs along the bottom, and up the side, instead of good and bad fortune, we measure proof that the company works. Anything in the deck that doesn’t move that line is scenery, the equivalent of describing Cinderella’s kingdom.
Nobody remembers what kingdom Cinderella lived in. Everyone remembers midnight.
The difference is, a founder isn’t telling a story to entertain. They tell one to inspire someone to take a leap of faith.
Where a company sits on its story arc determines how many leaps an investor has to take. A founder who knows their shape and where they sit along it knows which leaps they’ll be expected to address.
I've found seven recurring stories, roughly ordered by how difficult they are to finance. Not because they predict which companies will succeed, but because each asks investors to believe something different. And as a company's history grows, so does the evidence its next pitch has to explain.
The Golden Goose

It works, and the money makes the win bigger.
Things are going better than anyone promised, and the money only speeds it up.
My dad, an entrepreneur, told me the easiest way to get a bank to lend you money is to not need it. The pitch sounds like this: “I don’t need the money right now, but I could go a lot faster if you gave it to me.”
Maximum greed, minimum fear. These are the rounds investors fight over, and the founder sets the terms. The biggest question isn't whether it works. It's how big this can get.
Great Expectations

It It works. Now turn it into a business.
The technology works. The customers are there, and the path to a real business has gotten much clearer. Now comes the hard part: actually building it.
The simple version sounds like: “Customers have already placed orders. Now I need to figure out how to deliver a thousand times as many as I have already.” I’m betting on execution. The question is no longer whether the business can work, but whether this team can actually deliver it at scale.
The Last Locked Door

It looks like it works. One big thing is left to prove.
Most of the proof is in, but one consequential question remains. For hardware, it’s often a demonstration in the wild. For a medical device, it might be the FDA. Sometimes it’s a single technical result everything else depends on.
Unlike the last story, there's still that one question nobody can answer. And if the answer is no, the rest of the plan doesn't matter.
Deep tech lives here longer than anyone. A fusion company can stand at this point through three or four raises, and that’s the nature of the work. They don’t need to be through the door. They do need to show their key turns further in the lock than it did last time
Once Upon a Time

Seed a new thing.
The story starts today. There’s almost no evidence, so none of it points against the founder. I’m backing a team and a thesis on a clean sheet, and betting on whether the idea works at all.
It’s also the round everyone writes about. There are thousands of guides to the perfect YC demo day pitch, yet I’ve never seen one on how to pitch your third round. That's a shame, because every round after the first comes with a complication that no amount of storytelling advice can make disappear: your track record.
Here's the strange thing about seed fundraising: a company with almost nothing to show can be easier to finance than a Series B with $30 million worth of accomplishments.
This is the dividing line in these seven stories. The first four haven't materially missed any expectations yet. The last three have. Once you've raised money against a set of expectations, those expectations become part of your next pitch, whether you acknowledge them or not.
A clean slate is a powerful advantage. You only get one.
Waiting for Godot

It hasn’t worked yet, but the thesis is still right.
The last round was supposed to produce proof, and it produced less than promised. The founder is still certain Godot is coming. The world has been stubborn, and they’re going to show it. A lot of bridge rounds are really this story in disguise. Now I’m being asked to believe the original thesis still holds, even though the round meant to prove it came up short.
Sometimes they’re right, and most companies spend a round (or two…or three) here. Most founders in this story argue that the thesis still holds and say nothing about the slow progress, and they do themselves a disservice.
The gap between what they promised and where they are is the first thing I look at. Leaving it unaddressed doesn’t make it go away. Since I’ll be wondering what went wrong either way, the founder is better off accounting for it first. What moves me is a clear account of what the last round taught them.
We Climbed The Wrong Mountain

The thesis was wrong. We found a better one.
Maybe the product failed. Maybe it worked perfectly, but nobody wanted it badly enough. Either way, the company learned something fundamental: the original thesis was wrong.
Now the pitch is: "We were wrong about where this was going. But what we learned points somewhere better."
The hard part isn't just convincing me that the new opportunity is attractive. It's convincing me that this company is the right one to pursue it. Why should I finance the second attempt instead of backing a new team starting from scratch? The answer needs to lie in what the first attempt produced: technology, expertise, relationships, or insights that give this company an advantage the next one wouldn't have.
Sometimes the most successful experiment is the one that proves you were chasing the wrong opportunity.
A Series of Unfortunate Events

We screwed up. Fund the recovery.
The curve has gone up and down, and along the way the company picked up baggage: debt, overexpansion, broken economics, a team built for a plan that no longer exists. Unfortunately, the company needs to raise now, and the new money has to pay for past sins before it can fund the future. That’s a hard sell, because VCs like to fund growth and new development.
Running out of money comes with the territory. Landing here means the money went into things that now have to be undone.
Moving up the list
Read the list top to bottom and the bet changes. At the top, I’m betting on what the founder will build. By the bottom, I’m betting on their explanation of what happened.
The further down the list a company sits, the more tempting it is to put lipstick on the pig: pitching as if they’re standing at the last locked door when they’ve lived through a series of unfortunate events. It fools no one.
The best founders know exactly which story they’re in. That tells them which leaps they’re asking for, so they can address each one and bring their audience with them.
The other move is timing.
Here’s the (annoying) advice I’ve given numerous times this year alone: the best time to raise money is when it’s a good time for you to be raising money.
If you can afford to wait until after a breakthrough or a major risk is retired, do it. A milestone achieved before the raise can change which story you're in. The same milestone promised in the deck doesn't.
It’s never only investors
Remember, investors aren’t the only ones reading the shape of your story.
The engineer deciding whether to leave a comfortable job wants to know whether they’re tuning up a rocket for launch or plugging a leaky boat. The customer considering a major contract wants to know whether they will get a promotion for taking a smart bet, or fired for volunteering to be a startup’s guinea pig.
They're all asking the same question: Is this a story I want to be in?
And they're all reading the shape, whether you draw it for them or not.
— AF
1 There’s a brief and entertaining video of him teaching this. Watch it, and you’ll never read a novel the same way again.
2 Don’t be a Kafka ↓
